Napoleon Series Archive 2008

Re: Thanks to all for the information but it does

Speculation can lead us everywhere.
Both Massena's proclamation to the Portuguese in 1810 and Wellington's to the French in 1813 are very similar.
The difference is that while Wellington did everything to make it so, Massena eventually couldn't or didn't want to make it so. Of course Wellington was pushing in succesfully, while Massena was blocked out in Torres Vedras. Even so, Wellington risked and let loose some thousand Spanish troops and superiority of numbers, before he pushed further into France.

Anyway, at a certain point, the French people prefered to supply the Anglo-Portuguese, rather than their own army, thus creating some antagonism between the army and the people. This might indicate, among other things (the British bought, the French requisitioned), that the French people was receptive, as well as, in the contrary, the Portuguese people (after 1807-1809, and 2 invasions) were not.

My post is outside any claims of imperialism either French or British.

Jorge

Messages In This Thread

Wellesley and British outrages in Portugal
Re: Wellesley and British outrages in Portugal
Re: Wellesley and British outrages in Portugal
Re: Wellesley and British outrages in Portugal
What about soldiers in the Invasion of France???
Re: What about soldiers in the Invasion of France?
Re: What about soldiers in the Invasion of France?
Re: What about soldiers in the Invasion of France?
Thanks to all for the information but it does
Re: Thanks to all for the information but it does
Vidal de la Blache ii :-)
Re: Thanks to all for the information but it does
Discipline was the key
Re: Discipline was the key
Re: Discipline was the key
Re: Discipline was the key
Re: Discipline was the key
Covere Up or Coverup?
Re: Covere Up or Coverup?
Re: UP Covere
Re: Wellesley and British outrages in Portugal
Re: Wellesley and British outrages in Portugal
Re: Wellesley and British outrages in Portugal
Re: Wellesley and British outrages in Portugal
That Don would also raise the interesting query of
Re: That Don would also raise the interesting quer
Re: That Don would also raise the interesting quer
Re: That Don would also raise the interesting quer
Re: That Don would also raise the interesting quer
Re: That Don would also raise the interesting quer
Re: That Don would also raise the interesting quer
NVI - Interesting family history
Re: NVI - Interesting family history
Re: That Don would also raise the interesting quer
Re: That Don would also raise the interesting quer
Re: That Don would also raise the interesting quer
People you trust
Re: People you trust
Don Were your family in any battles or any of the
Re: Don Were your family in any battles or any of
Re: That Don would also raise the interesting quer
Maryland, My Maryland
Re: Maryland, My Maryland
Re: Wellesley and British outrages in Portugal
Re: Wellesley and British outrages in Portugal