Napoleon Series Archive 2017

1st rank kneeling & 3rd rank fire

Hallo,
just to settle a dispute.
Although often found in papers like regulations, was it so in the field that when a 3 rank unit in line delivered fire that the 1st rank usually kneeled and the 3rd rank fired over their heads?
AFAIK neeling was seldom used by formed units, except for squares. and with that the 3rd ranks fire caused more problems then benefit and so wasn't used much if at all.
With regards

Messages In This Thread

1st rank kneeling & 3rd rank fire
Re: 1st rank kneeling & 3rd rank fire
Re: 1st rank kneeling & 3rd rank fire
Re: 1st rank kneeling & 3rd rank fire
Re: 1st rank kneeling & 3rd rank fire
Re: 1st rank kneeling & 3rd rank fire
Re: 1st rank kneeling & 3rd rank fire
Re: 1st rank kneeling & 3rd rank fire
Re: 1st rank kneeling & 3rd rank fire
Re: 1st rank kneeling & 3rd rank fire
Re: 1st rank kneeling & 3rd rank fire
Re: 1st rank kneeling & 3rd rank fire
Clausewitz' account
Re: Clausewitz' account
Re: Clausewitz' account
Re: 1st rank kneeling & 3rd rank fire
Re: 1st rank kneeling & 3rd rank fire
Re: 1st rank kneeling & 3rd rank fire
Re: 1st rank kneeling & 3rd rank fire
Re: 1st rank kneeling & 3rd rank fire
Re: 1st rank kneeling & 3rd rank fire
Re: 1st rank kneeling & 3rd rank fire
Re: 1st rank kneeling & 3rd rank fire
Re: 1st rank kneeling & 3rd rank fire
Re: 1st rank kneeling & 3rd rank fire
Re: 1st rank kneeling & 3rd rank fire
Re: 1st rank kneeling & 3rd rank fire
Re: 1st rank kneeling & 3rd rank fire
Re: 1st rank kneeling & 3rd rank fire