Barkhausen, Georg Heinrich

Check also Dr. Maag about the Suisse in Spain, he cites from a lot of diaries from those units which were captured at Baylen, you will find out a lot about the hulks at Cadiz and Cabrera, also that he agrees a lot with Titeux (despite not knowing his work and relating on myth maker Thiers.

So all generals who loose battle or cock up campaings should be punished?
Sorry to day that also here I disagree.

At least they should get a fair trial and not a farce as Dupont or other distinguished officers - Moreau.

According to your rules Napoleon himself should be court martialed after the disastrous Russian campaign of 1812 - surly much worse than Dupont at Baylen, which pales against Russia.