Napoleon Series Archive 2008

Re: Inquisition ?
In Response To: Inquisition ? ()

In some sort, these actions can also be seen as inquisition.

Marc,

I fear we drift too far off topic.

However, your point is well taken. The institution lives on in a changed form. In the U.S., the Protestant Evangelicals and the Roman Catholic Bishops have joined forces to instill their theologic ideas into the civil law.

I opine that the difference is that in the period of this forum's discussion, the "Inquisition" as a separate institution of the RC church which none-the-less exercised civil authority, was falling into disrepute. In Spain, it served the monarchy as the civil arm of censorship.

Napoleon is castigated for his control of the press. Yet who else did not have an official censor who could close down newspapers and prohibit books? It is famous that books were "banned in Boston" through a good part of the 20th century. Naturally that made them sell very well elsewhere.

When I ask Europeans and Americans, "How did Voltaire become concerned with Jean Calas, and why is [was] this an important event in the history of freedom of religion?" -- the most frequent answer from even the educated and well read is, "who the hell is Jean Calas?"

Why flog Napoleon's warts and graces when not very much has changed since then?

Very best regards, BaldJim

Messages In This Thread

Ogres, Demons, and Perfidious Albion...
Here comes another red herring
Re: Here comes another red herring
Re: Here comes another red herring
Re: Here comes another red herring
Re: Here comes another red herring
Re: Here comes another red herring
red herring definition
Re: Here comes another red herring
I guess it depends on who you were captured by
PWs Never Have a Nice Day
Re: PWs Never Have a Nice Day
Perhaps ....
Re: Perhaps ....
Re: Ogres, Demons, and Perfidious Albion...
Re: Ogres, Demons, and Perfidious Albion...
Re: Ogres, Demons, and Perfidious Albion...
Re: Ogres, Demons, and Perfidious Albion...
Re: Ogres, Demons, and Perfidious Albion...
Re: Ogres, Demons, and Perfidious Albion...
Re: Ogres, Demons, and Perfidious Albion...
Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Your right of course Digby it also violated
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Try ...
Or ...
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Are but you forget the average Joe will more
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Centrifugal political force in Spain
Inquisition ?
Re: Inquisition ?
Re: Georges Blond *LINK*
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Perhaps Susan but might that also be because
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Spanish Inquisition
Re: Spanish Inquisition
Re: Georges Blond
Tone's review of Esdaile
Re: Tone's review of Esdaile
Esdaile, Napoleon and Spain
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Ogres, Demons, and Perfidious Albion...