Napoleon Series Archive 2008

Re: Georges Blond
In Response To: Re: Georges Blond ()

Jim,

Even if being kind to bystanders is not a military priority in its own right, there are surely three good military reasons for preventing individual plundering:

1, that a hostile population can be dangerous;
2, that it made collecting official contributions difficult, which Napoleon did complain of;
3, that troops which scatter to plunder are difficult to control.

There is also the difficulty of transporting the loot once it is collected - as in Russia.

The Directory had a big drive to remove dishonest generals in 1799 but it caused so much unpopularity that the relevant Directors got removed instead. I would have thought Napoleon was in a rather stronger position.

regards,

Susan

Messages In This Thread

Ogres, Demons, and Perfidious Albion...
Here comes another red herring
Re: Here comes another red herring
Re: Here comes another red herring
Re: Here comes another red herring
Re: Here comes another red herring
Re: Here comes another red herring
red herring definition
Re: Here comes another red herring
I guess it depends on who you were captured by
PWs Never Have a Nice Day
Re: PWs Never Have a Nice Day
Perhaps ....
Re: Perhaps ....
Re: Ogres, Demons, and Perfidious Albion...
Re: Ogres, Demons, and Perfidious Albion...
Re: Ogres, Demons, and Perfidious Albion...
Re: Ogres, Demons, and Perfidious Albion...
Re: Ogres, Demons, and Perfidious Albion...
Re: Ogres, Demons, and Perfidious Albion...
Re: Ogres, Demons, and Perfidious Albion...
Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Your right of course Digby it also violated
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Try ...
Or ...
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Are but you forget the average Joe will more
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Centrifugal political force in Spain
Inquisition ?
Re: Inquisition ?
Re: Georges Blond *LINK*
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Perhaps Susan but might that also be because
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Spanish Inquisition
Re: Spanish Inquisition
Re: Georges Blond
Tone's review of Esdaile
Re: Tone's review of Esdaile
Esdaile, Napoleon and Spain
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Georges Blond
Re: Ogres, Demons, and Perfidious Albion...