Napoleon Series Archive 2013

Re: Davout vs. Bernadotte 1813
In Response To: Re: Davout vs. Bernadotte 1813 ()

Davout's conduct in Hamburg was considered a 'war crime' by whom? False charges were brought against him by the Bourbons after Davout returned to France and Davout successfully defended himself against the false charges.

Davout never lost, took proper care of the troops in his charge and was an admirable man and soldier. The same cannot be said for Bernadotte or Dupont. Dupont allowed looting in Spain, something Davout never did, and it has been shown that Bernadotte was an unreliable subordinate and comrade.

I don't see a problem with a commander being 'ruthless' in the accomplishment of his mission.

Sincerely,
M

Messages In This Thread

Who hated whom?
Re: Who hated whom?
Re: the marshals seldom failed each other
Re: Who hated whom?
Re: Who hated whom?
Re: Who hated whom?
Re: Who hated whom?
General Officer Relationships
Davout vs. Bernadotte 1813
Re: Davout vs. Bernadotte 1813
Re: Davout vs. Bernadotte 1813
Re: Davout vs. Bernadotte 1813
Re: Davout vs. Bernadotte 1813
Re: Davout vs. Bernadotte 1813
Re: Davout vs. Bernadotte 1813
Re: Davout vs. Bernadotte 1813
Re: Crhistmastide
Re: Davout vs. Bernadotte 1813
Re: Davout vs. Bernadotte 1813
Re: Davout vs. Bernadotte 1813
Re: Davout vs. Bernadotte 1813
Re: Davout vs. Bernadotte 1813
Re: Davout vs. Bernadotte 1813
Re: Davout vs. Bernadotte 1813
Re: Davout vs. Bernadotte 1813
Morals of the time, how should they be judged then
Re: Morals of the time, how should they be judged
Re: Morals of the time, how should they be judged
Re: Morals of the time, how should they be judged *LINK*
Re: Davout vs. Bernadotte 1813
Re: Davout vs. Bernadotte 1813
Didn't Davout lose at Ratisbon
Re: Who hated whom?
Re: Who hated whom?
Re: Who hated whom? *LINK*
Re: Who hated whom?