Napoleon Series Archive 2008

Re: Soult's "thefts"
In Response To: Re: Soult's "thefts" ()

The French army CODE MILITAIRE prohibited stealing or plunder and the CODE PENAL provided penalties -- up to and including capital punishment -- for transgressors. As we have already established, these two documents were in force in 1813 and probably to the end of the empire.

If evidence is forthcoming that senior French officers plundered than they should, by their own army's military law, have been subject to a court martial and, if found guilty, punished.

If they were not subjected to a court martial or, if found guilty, not punished, we can only deduce two things:

a) French senior officers were exempt from the provisions of the army's military law, or

b) the French army did not follow its own military law on this matter.

I tend toward (b) but then I am cynical. If solid evidence is forthcoming that French senior officers looted or plundered between 1796 (the year the CODE PENAL went into force) and 1815, we can apply the above and make some conclusions about the discipline of the French army.

dg

Messages In This Thread

Soult's "thefts"
Historia del levantamiento
Re: Soult's "thefts"
Re: Soult's "thefts"
Re: Soult's "thefts"
Re: Soult's "thefts"
Did not Napoleon himself remark that
Re: Did not Napoleon himself remark that
It might be an over simplification but it seems
Re: It might be an over simplification but it seem
I ment in the fact
Re: It might be an over simplification but it seem
Long List
Re: Long List
Re: Long List
Proto Marxist Don!!!!
Fantastical American Memory - Collectivized
Hans-Lothar von Pivka and his work
a small reality gap
Re: Did not Napoleon himself remark that
I cannot remmember prescialy
Re: Did not Napoleon himself remark that
Re: Soult's "thefts"
Re: Soult's "thefts"
Re: Soult's "thefts"
Re: Soult's "thefts"
Re: Soult's "thefts"
Re: Soult's "thefts"
The Vicissitudes Of Pictures.
Re: The Vicissitudes Of Pictures.
"... The Mythology Of The Soult Collection ...."
Oft-Repeated Details About The Soult Collection
The "Monk's Tale".
Re: Oft-Repeated Details About The Soult Collectio
bordel ambulant
Re: bordel ambulant
Re: bordel ambulant
Re: bordel ambulant
Re: bordel ambulant
Re: bordel ambulant
Re: bordel ambulant
Re: bordel ambulant
the letter is about refugees
Refugees, try this
Re: Refugees, try this
Re: the letter is about refugees
Re: the letter is about refugees
Re: bordel ambulant
The Robert ! :-)
Re: bordel ambulant
Quite So, However ....
Re: Quite So, However ....
Re: bordel ambulant
Re: bordel ambulant
Re: bordel ambulant
Re: bordel ambulant
Re: bordel ambulant
Re: trois capotes anglaises ! *NM*
Re: bordel ambulant
BMC
Stolen Masterpieces.
Soult's "art collection" and its provenance
Re: Soult's "art collection" and its provenance
Soult, Sevilla and Salvation
Re: Soult's "art collection" and its provenance
Re: Soult's "thefts" *LINK*
Saint-Chamans Downloads.
Re: Saint-Chamans Downloads.
Soult and the "Obras de Misericordia"
articles