Napoleon Series Archive 2008

Re: the letter is about refugees

Susan, the letter is about women in Bayonne and in the départements of France adjacent to Spain. The army was, however, not in those locations. Hence we are not talking about camp followers. Indeed, there was an entire civil administration that required evacuation.

I am sure there were camp followers among these people, but the letter is clearly not reflecting Napoléon holding the view that the French army was a mobile brothel, the spin you gave in when you quoted the letter.
"As for the mobile brothel, whatever the exact phrasing, it appears to have been a fair description, to judge by Napoleon's reaction:"

You can think anything you like of the letter, of course. But I would not expect anyone who can read French to agree with the spin you gave to the slanted English (mis-)translation.

Messages In This Thread

Soult's "thefts"
Historia del levantamiento
Re: Soult's "thefts"
Re: Soult's "thefts"
Re: Soult's "thefts"
Re: Soult's "thefts"
Did not Napoleon himself remark that
Re: Did not Napoleon himself remark that
It might be an over simplification but it seems
Re: It might be an over simplification but it seem
I ment in the fact
Re: It might be an over simplification but it seem
Long List
Re: Long List
Re: Long List
Proto Marxist Don!!!!
Fantastical American Memory - Collectivized
Hans-Lothar von Pivka and his work
a small reality gap
Re: Did not Napoleon himself remark that
I cannot remmember prescialy
Re: Did not Napoleon himself remark that
Re: Soult's "thefts"
Re: Soult's "thefts"
Re: Soult's "thefts"
Re: Soult's "thefts"
Re: Soult's "thefts"
Re: Soult's "thefts"
The Vicissitudes Of Pictures.
Re: The Vicissitudes Of Pictures.
"... The Mythology Of The Soult Collection ...."
Oft-Repeated Details About The Soult Collection
The "Monk's Tale".
Re: Oft-Repeated Details About The Soult Collectio
bordel ambulant
Re: bordel ambulant
Re: bordel ambulant
Re: bordel ambulant
Re: bordel ambulant
Re: bordel ambulant
Re: bordel ambulant
Re: bordel ambulant
the letter is about refugees
Refugees, try this
Re: Refugees, try this
Re: the letter is about refugees
Re: the letter is about refugees
Re: bordel ambulant
The Robert ! :-)
Re: bordel ambulant
Quite So, However ....
Re: Quite So, However ....
Re: bordel ambulant
Re: bordel ambulant
Re: bordel ambulant
Re: bordel ambulant
Re: bordel ambulant
Re: trois capotes anglaises ! *NM*
Re: bordel ambulant
BMC
Stolen Masterpieces.
Soult's "art collection" and its provenance
Re: Soult's "art collection" and its provenance
Soult, Sevilla and Salvation
Re: Soult's "art collection" and its provenance
Re: Soult's "thefts" *LINK*
Saint-Chamans Downloads.
Re: Saint-Chamans Downloads.
Soult and the "Obras de Misericordia"
articles