Napoleon Series Archive 2008

Re: paint me stupid...
In Response To: Re: paint me stupid... ()

Ralph or rather Ney - explained it very well, a battalion column has usually a frontage of one company or peloton one behind each other, such was the understanding when the authors spoke of a battalion column.

I also would agree that a colonnes serrées par regiment, is one battalion column (of peloton width) behind each ohter.

No other colonnes are described in the regulations, how would you form a regiment in a column of battalion width? You would first have to deploy each battalion in line and then form then into a column.

The problem with the colonne d'attaque (my all time favourite) and why it came out of fashion was - that on the approach march - usually columns of peloton width were used, so to form a colonne d'attaque, those would first have to form a line and then again a column, akward.

By that - instead they just formed either

1. a battlion column
2. a battlion column by divisions with to the left, see the link Ralph supplied.

HK

Messages In This Thread

Re: A French Formation description Art?
Re: A French Formation description Art?
Re: A French Formation description Art?
Re: A French Formation description Art?
Re: A French Formation description Art?
Re: A French Formation description Art?
paint me stupid...
Re: paint me stupid...
Re: paint me stupid...
From Journal des sciences militaires 1832 *LINK*
Re: From Journal des sciences militaires 1832
Re: paint me stupid...
Ney's description
Re: Ney's description
Re: Ney's description *LINK*
Re: Ney's description
Re: Ney's description
Re: Ney's description
Difference
Maransin
Re: Maransin
Re: Difference
Re: Difference
Re: Difference
Re: Difference
Re: Difference
Attack columns *LINK*
Re: Attack columns
Re: Attack columns
Re: Ney's description
understanding the term of....
Re: Ney's description
Re: Ney's description
Re: Ney's description
Re: Ney's description
Re: Ney's description
Re: Ney's description
Re: Ney's description
Understanding Ney's Military Studies
Re: Understanding Ney's Military Studies
Re: Understanding Ney's Military Studies
Re: Understanding Ney's Military Studies
And Jomini Says ....
Re: And Jomini Says ....
Re: Ney's description
Military studies: ... for the use of his officers.
Re: Ney's description
Mémoires du Maréchal Ney/Memoirs of Marshal Ney.
Re: paint me stupid...
Re: paint me stupid...
Context Matters
Context is everything...
Re: Context is everything...
Re: Context is everything... :-) *NM*
Re: Context is everything...
Re: Context is everything...
Morand's Comment on Columns *LINK*
change of front
Re: change of front
Re: paint me stupid...
Re: paint me stupid...
Re: paint me stupid...