Napoleon Series Archive 2008

Re: Difference
In Response To: Re: Difference ()

You wrote:

Maransin corrects Lapene in his later writings by saying that Girard was in 'attack columns' and Gazan was in 'attack columns by battalion'.

I believe this could be edited to say:

Maransin adds to Lapene's account by saying that Girard was in 'attack columns' and Gazan was in 'a series of battalion columns'.

In this sense, both are possible and thus Maransin is expanding upon what Lapene wrote and not "correcting" the 'attack column' aspect, but to say the several attack columns are a series of columns.

If you have the original French of Maransin (which I seem not to have, though I thought I did), I could verify this. - R

Messages In This Thread

Re: A French Formation description Art?
Re: A French Formation description Art?
Re: A French Formation description Art?
Re: A French Formation description Art?
Re: A French Formation description Art?
Re: A French Formation description Art?
paint me stupid...
Re: paint me stupid...
Re: paint me stupid...
From Journal des sciences militaires 1832 *LINK*
Re: From Journal des sciences militaires 1832
Re: paint me stupid...
Ney's description
Re: Ney's description
Re: Ney's description *LINK*
Re: Ney's description
Re: Ney's description
Re: Ney's description
Difference
Maransin
Re: Maransin
Re: Difference
Re: Difference
Re: Difference
Re: Difference
Re: Difference
Attack columns *LINK*
Re: Attack columns
Re: Attack columns
Re: Ney's description
understanding the term of....
Re: Ney's description
Re: Ney's description
Re: Ney's description
Re: Ney's description
Re: Ney's description
Re: Ney's description
Re: Ney's description
Understanding Ney's Military Studies
Re: Understanding Ney's Military Studies
Re: Understanding Ney's Military Studies
Re: Understanding Ney's Military Studies
And Jomini Says ....
Re: And Jomini Says ....
Re: Ney's description
Military studies: ... for the use of his officers.
Re: Ney's description
Mémoires du Maréchal Ney/Memoirs of Marshal Ney.
Re: paint me stupid...
Re: paint me stupid...
Context Matters
Context is everything...
Re: Context is everything...
Re: Context is everything... :-) *NM*
Re: Context is everything...
Re: Context is everything...
Morand's Comment on Columns *LINK*
change of front
Re: change of front
Re: paint me stupid...
Re: paint me stupid...
Re: paint me stupid...