Napoleon Series Archive 2008

Re: Ney's description
In Response To: Re: Ney's description ()

Rod wrote:
These then form four close columns of regiments, the
second battalion behind the first. The columns close laterally to a single
battalion deploying distance. When each battalion deploys they will be in two
lines, the first line of all the 1st battalions of the 4 regiments and the
second line of the 2nd battalions.

Rod:
It is clear to me now :b , and Ralph has helped a great deal. Your reading makes sense and agrees with Ralph. However, I find the call to go to columns of regiments a curious extra step when two lines are being formed. It means bringing together two battalions into contact as a single column on the way to form two lines that will typically be a hundred or so yards apart on the battlefield. Forming lines following Ney's instructions would have the lines less than 30 yards apart once deployed. [12 ranks deep plus spacing for the battalion column in four divisions.]

Certainly 'fixing it' is no big problem. The first line simply marches out to the desired distance from the second. It does imply that it is easier forming a single column before deploying, than marching one battalion out 100 yards behind the one in front before deploying. The concern about alignment is clear in Ney's instructions. bring four columns within deployment distance would be easier to do than eight in two lines 100 yards apart.

Best Regards,

Bill H.

Messages In This Thread

Re: A French Formation description Art?
Re: A French Formation description Art?
Re: A French Formation description Art?
Re: A French Formation description Art?
Re: A French Formation description Art?
Re: A French Formation description Art?
paint me stupid...
Re: paint me stupid...
Re: paint me stupid...
From Journal des sciences militaires 1832 *LINK*
Re: From Journal des sciences militaires 1832
Re: paint me stupid...
Ney's description
Re: Ney's description
Re: Ney's description *LINK*
Re: Ney's description
Re: Ney's description
Re: Ney's description
Difference
Maransin
Re: Maransin
Re: Difference
Re: Difference
Re: Difference
Re: Difference
Re: Difference
Attack columns *LINK*
Re: Attack columns
Re: Attack columns
Re: Ney's description
understanding the term of....
Re: Ney's description
Re: Ney's description
Re: Ney's description
Re: Ney's description
Re: Ney's description
Re: Ney's description
Re: Ney's description
Understanding Ney's Military Studies
Re: Understanding Ney's Military Studies
Re: Understanding Ney's Military Studies
Re: Understanding Ney's Military Studies
And Jomini Says ....
Re: And Jomini Says ....
Re: Ney's description
Military studies: ... for the use of his officers.
Re: Ney's description
Mémoires du Maréchal Ney/Memoirs of Marshal Ney.
Re: paint me stupid...
Re: paint me stupid...
Context Matters
Context is everything...
Re: Context is everything...
Re: Context is everything... :-) *NM*
Re: Context is everything...
Re: Context is everything...
Morand's Comment on Columns *LINK*
change of front
Re: change of front
Re: paint me stupid...
Re: paint me stupid...
Re: paint me stupid...